One Prattville man is dead, a woman is in critical condition and a Montgomery man has been charged with homicide by vessel and boating under the influence after a horrific boating accident on Lake Martin.

Patrick Cumbie, 22, is in the Elmore County Jail under $15,000 bond for the death of Donny Tatum, a 62-year-old Prattville man, according to the Alabama Marine Police. Tatum’s sister-in-law, Sue Tatum, is in critical condition after suffering life-threatening injuries, said Whit Moncrief, who is a Prattville resident and a friend of the victims.

Three other people suffered injuries and were taken to hospitals in Tallassee and Montgomery, said Marine Police Sgt. Gary Buchanan, who worked the crash. He did not believe their injuries were life-threatening.

Buchanan said there were people in the water around the stern of a pontoon boat when Cumbie ran over some of them and crashed his runabout into the right rear of the pontoon boat. There were “about 11 people” on the boat or in the water when the accident happened at 11:30 p.m. Saturday, he added.

Buchanan said he thought all the people on the pontoon boat were from Prattville, but it was hard to determine in the chaotic scene that followed the accident.

“In a boating accident you have the added dangers and complications presented by the lake itself,” he said in a news release issued after the accident. “You can’t just drive an ambulance out onto the water to get to the injured.”

Buchanan said Cumbie was arrested and charged with boating under the influence, which was increased to homicide by vessel when the victim died.

Buchanan said the accident took place in the Little Kowaliga Creek section of Lake Martin near Real Island Marina.

“They were in open water as far as I know,” said Buchanan, who arrived after the collision and began rescue operations. “They were not at a dock.”

Officers from the Eclectic Police Department, deputies from the Elmore County Sheriff’s Department and members of the Kowaliga Volunteer Fire Department responded to assist. He said neither boat sank and both were driven back to the dock at Sinclair’s, a popular restaurant on the Elmore County side of Lake Martin near Alabama 63.

Buchanan said a couple of helicopters and multiple ambulances rushed to the scene to evacuate the injured.

“Everything involved with the accident is still under investigation,” Buchanan said.



We're here to help!

We live by our creed of "helping those who need it most" and have helped thousands of clients get the justice they desperately needed and deserved. If you feel you have a case or just have questions please contact us for a free consultation. There is no risk and no fees unless we win for you.

Fields marked    may be required for submission.
  1. I'm an attorney

Beasley Allen attorney Kendall Dunson discusses...

Dunson encourages viewers who are tenants of apartment complexes to take certain steps to determine if...

Kendall Dunson discusses the Mobile Port Accident and...

In this edition of the Beasley Allen Report, host Gibson Vance speaks with Beasley Allen shareholder...

Beasley Allen lawyer Gibson Vance discusses golf cart...

Golf carts have left the fairways and taken to the streets as a popular mode of transportation in...

Beasley Allen's Mike Andrews discusses contaminated...

Beasley Allen attorney Mike Andrews tells NBC affiliate Alabama's13.com the "short story" of a man who...

Beasley Allen lawyer Mike Andrews talks about...

This week, Beasley Allen lawyer Mike Andrews filed a lawsuit on behalf of a man who claims he contracted...

Aviation accidents -- a look at a helicopter crash case

Gibson Vance talks with Beasley Allen lawyer Chris Glover about an aviation accident case that involved...

Continuing the battle with Big Pharma

The entire Beasley Allen staff had our personal interest at heart. We were part of the family of a down to earth, trustworthy, understanding law firm. Thank you, Beasley Allen, for continuing the battle with Big Pharma.

—Richard