Plaintiffs’ lawyers are awaiting a decision on which federal court will handle the bulk of the Toyota Motor Corp. sudden acceleration litigation.

Nearly 200 lawsuits have been filed so far in federal and state courts throughout the country. The litigation involves both individual personal injury suits and consumer class actions filed on behalf of Toyota owners who claim that the value of their vehicles has been battered by concerns about sudden unintended acceleration.

On March 25, the Joint Panel on Multi-District Litigation heard one-minute pitches from about two dozen lawyers seeking to consolidate consumer and personal injury suits in their jurisdictions.

W. Daniel Miles, head of the consumer fraud section at Beasley Allen in Montgomery, Ala., said he deferred his time to an attorney who spoke on behalf of several states.

But Miles said that the lawyers’ presentations will have little impact on the panel’s decision.

“The panel will do what it wants, and the presentations were of no real merit,” he asserted.

Miles said the front-runner appears to be the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana is a “clear second,” he added, with the federal court in Minnesota as a wild card venue.

“Wherever it lands will then determine who will be in leadership to steer the litigation,” Miles said.

Beasley Allen has filed a total of five consumer class actions so far in four states – Alabama, California, Florida and Georgia – as well as one wrongful death case in state court in Alabama.

Stephen J. Herman, a partner at Herman, Herman, Katz & Cotlar in New Orleans, was not at the MDL hearing, but said he has heard rumors that the Toyota MDL may land in New Orleans.

“If so, and we are asked to serve on the [plaintiffs’ steering] committee, we likely will,” he said.

J. David Prince, a professor at William Mitchell College of Law in St. Paul, Minn., said that lawyers want a leadership role because it puts them in a better position to determine case strategy.

“Secondarily – and I really do think it’s a secondary consideration – it means they’ll get a bigger share of the fees,” he said.

As far as which court is designated the MDL court, Prince said lawyers care about it for the same reason they always care about choice of venue: “Different judges have different attitudes and approaches to various issues.”

For example, a court that is reluctant to grant summary judgment motions might be preferred by plaintiffs, while one that is more inclined to grant Daubert challenges might be preferred by defendants, he explained.

“The choice of MDL court can mean a lot in determining how many cases will eventually move forward to trial or settlement,” Prince said.

Steve W. Berman, a partner at Hagens, Berman, Sobol, Shapiro in Seattle, wrote in an e-mail that he predicted the MDL will include both consumer class actions and personal injury lawsuits, and that it will be “all in one place” – the Central District of California.

Last week, Berman’s firm filed class actions in five states – Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Maryland and Washington – demanding refunds for Toyota owners.

Toyota, with its U.S. headquarters based in Torrance, Calif., has requested that the MDL be located in the Central District of California.

The Japanese automaker has recalled more than 8 million vehicles for repairs related to sudden, unintended acceleration.

Questions or comments can be directed to the writer at: nora.tooher@lawyersusaonline.com



We're here to help!

We live by our creed of "helping those who need it most" and have helped thousands of clients get the justice they desperately needed and deserved. If you feel you have a case or just have questions please contact us for a free consultation. There is no risk and no fees unless we win for you.

Fields marked    may be required for submission.
  1. I'm an attorney

VW sudden acceleration case explained by Beasley...

Beasley Allen attorney Mike Andrews visited Ringler Radio to discuss a case of sudden unintended...
Kendall Dunson & Mike Andrews outside courthouse after Volkswagen verdict

Federal Judge denies Volkswagen, Honeywell request for...

U.S. District Judge Clay D. Land on Tuesday denied a request from Volkswagen Group of America Inc. and...
2014 Trial Lawyer of the Year nominees, Graham Esdale, Ben Baker and Cole Portis

Beasley Allen, Toyota trial team recognized as...

Four attorneys from Beasley, Allen, Crow, Methvin, Portis & Miles, P.C., were selected as finalists for...
Nominees, Jere Beasley, Cole Portis, Ben Baker and Graham Esdale

Beasley Allen lawyers nominated for 2014 Public...

The Toyota trial team including Beasley Allen lawyers Jere L. Beasley, J. Cole Portis, R. Graham Esdale...
Toyota Settlement

Toyota pays record fine on the heels of landmark...

A settlement of $1.2 billion will be paid by Toyota
Toyota Settlement

Toyota must pay largest penalty of any car...

Record-breaking fines will be paid to resolve a four-year criminal investigation by the federal...

I never dreamed how much this would mean to me

I received another check today, much to my surprise. Thank you, thank you, thank you! I never dreamed how much this would mean to me in my golden years, as I have had hearing problems for years and needed to update my hearing aids, but with a limited income, found that was impossible. I now have the best hearing aids that I have ever had, thanks to you fighting so hard on my behalf.

—Gladys